⮉

Загрузите GEDCOM-файл на ВГД   [х]
Всероссийское Генеалогическое Древо
На сайте ВГД собираются люди, увлеченные генеалогией, историей, геральдикой и т.д. Здесь вы найдете собеседников, экспертов, умелых помощников в поисках предков и родственников. Вам подскажут где искать документы о павших в боях и пропавших без вести, в какой архив обратиться при исследовании родословной своей семьи, помогут определить по старой фотографии принадлежность к воинским частям, ведомствам и чину. ВГД - поиск людей в прошлом, настоящем и будущем!
Раздел Message board » People and ancestors search in Russia » For English speaking users; Für Deutschsprechende
Вниз ⇊

DNA test

Information for DNA testing

← Назад    Вперед →Страницы: 1 *
Модератор: Andrey Maslennikov
FuranNietchaieff

Сообщений: 223
На сайте с 2023 г.
Рейтинг: 44
Наверх   ## 17 февраля 0:55
>> Ответ на сообщение пользователя olga_clarke от 17 февраля 2025 0:05

ah I understand why I saw genotek sometimes. I've dealt with Myheritage before, I don't mind doing it again.
ONLINE
galinamelnikova
Начинающий

galinamelnikova

Тутаев
Сообщений: 26
На сайте с 2021 г.
Рейтинг: 38
Наверх   ## 17 февраля 18:15

FuranNietchaieff написал:
[q]
Good evening,
I would like to make a DNA test for my grand mother. The idea is to use the best laboratory witch have the most important Polish/slave poeple in their data base so I can find cousin and good geography result. I did some research and I have the impression that there is no laboratory in Russian? Most, I think, use FTDNA, is this still relevant? I know MyHeritage and Ancestry have a pretty good data base. Is this kind of test something that is common in Eastern Europe?
[/q]



Hello FuranNietchaieff 101.gif

There is a Russian laboratory called Genotek.

If you are of Polish descent, I strongly suggest you consider getting tested on AncestryDNA or 23andMe. They both have a large number of Polish testers in their databases.

I would not recommend MyHeritage for a serious pursuit of unknown origins in your family tree. Their algorithms are bit unclear even in the newest version (v2.5), released just recently.
AncestryDNA has over 700,000 SNPs (approximately equivalent to FTDNA), 23andMe has 500,000 SNPs in their genotypes, and it is clear that the more SNPs, the more accurate the results.

AncestryDNA and MyHeritage don't provide Y-DNA and mtDNA haplogroups, which is different from 23andMe and Genotek as they do.
FuranNietchaieff

Сообщений: 223
На сайте с 2023 г.
Рейтинг: 44
Наверх   ## 17 февраля 21:38
[/q]

Hello FuranNietchaieff

There is a Russian laboratory called Genotek.

If you are of Polish descent, I strongly suggest you consider getting tested on AncestryDNA or 23andMe. They both have a large number of Polish testers in their databases.

I would not recommend MyHeritage for a serious pursuit of unknown origins in your family tree. Their algorithms are bit unclear even in the newest version (v2.5), released just recently.
AncestryDNA has over 700,000 SNPs (approximately equivalent to FTDNA), 23andMe has 500,000 SNPs in their genotypes, and it is clear that the more SNPs, the more accurate the results.

AncestryDNA and MyHeritage don't provide Y-DNA and mtDNA haplogroups, which is different from 23andMe and Genotek as they do.
[/q]



Quite interesting ! You make me think again about my choice. My origine come from Polish, Belarus and West Russia.
ONLINE
galinamelnikova
Начинающий

galinamelnikova

Тутаев
Сообщений: 26
На сайте с 2021 г.
Рейтинг: 38
Наверх   ## 17 февраля 22:01

FuranNietchaieff написал:
[q]
Quite interesting ! You make me think again about my choice. My origine come from Polish, Belarus and West Russia.
[/q]


I can give you more information about DNA testing. Have you ever done before? Have you heard of 3rd party tools such as G25 coordinates?
If you live outside of Russia, you can upload your raw DNA to genotek.eu (not the .ru version because it won't allow you to open it).
Лайк (1)
FuranNietchaieff

Сообщений: 223
На сайте с 2023 г.
Рейтинг: 44
Наверх   ## 18 февраля 13:25
I have already done a DNA test before, it was with myheritage but not for my branch coming from eastern europe.
I do not know G25.
I will do that for genotek thank you
ONLINE
Лайк (1)
tIEWbTizk3xdUPYo
Новичок

Сообщений: 6
На сайте с 2024 г.
Рейтинг: 8
Наверх   ## 31 марта 19:05
>> Ответ на сообщение пользователя olga_clarke от 17 февраля 2025 0:05

Followed the instructions at Genotek to download the Ancestry DNA data, but I receive an error message that data is corrupted or erroneous when try to upload the txt, zip, or csv dataset to their website. The problem may be with Genotek, as the same DNA files worked fine with other websites such as MyHeritage DNA upload.
tIEWbTizk3xdUPYo
Новичок

Сообщений: 6
На сайте с 2024 г.
Рейтинг: 8
Наверх   ## 1 апреля 17:48

tIEWbTizk3xdUPYo написал:
[q]
>> Reply to message from user olga_clarke from February 17, 2025 0:05

Followed the instructions at Genotek to download the Ancestry DNA data, but I receive an error message that data is corrupted or erroneous when try to upload the txt, zip, or csv dataset to their website. The problem may be with Genotek, as the same DNA files worked fine with other websites such as MyHeritage DNA upload.
[/q]


Additions:
- No reply yet from Genotek as to why uploads of DNA datasets fail, nor why their website is not allowing new accounts to be created (the confirmation code via e-mail is not being sent out)
- Be cautious with MyHeritage. After creating new free account and uploading data, attempting to log in again gives repeated error message that "Access has been temporarily disabled. Your access has been temporarily disabled due to irregular activity. Please try again in 24 hours."
- FamilyTreeDNA appears to work fine. Can upload data and get relative matches within a few hours.
← Назад    Вперед →Страницы: 1 *
Модератор: Andrey Maslennikov
Генеалогический форум » Message board » People and ancestors search in Russia » For English speaking users; Für Deutschsprechende » DNA test [тема №164497]
Вверх ⇈